As a long-time Cowboys fan, I have wrestled with The Annual Dilemma - are we going to the Super Bowl or will we have Football Armageddon (again)...
In any event, we have ourselves a fine argument coming up. A 4th Round Pick stepping in for an injured Un-drafted Free Agent (let's not forget that). I was thinking 8-8 realistically and maybe 10-6 if some things swing the Cowboys way. Now, its 6-10 realistically and 8-8 if some things swing the Cowboys way.
So, what do I base this optimism on? (It should be pointed out that 6-10 would actually be an IMPROVEMENT from last year...) The newly installed Rookie Starter Drafted in the 4th Round .... actually doesn't look half-bad. At least, tons better than Weed-Man or Or-Ton.
Anyway, riffing on a "Hey Cowboys Fans, step back from the Window Ledge" piece from 538.com, I wanted to confirm how successful Rookie NFL QBs have been.
Rookie Opening Day Starters: 38 (since 1970)
Rookie QBs That Won 8+ Games: 12
- Joe Ferguson for the Buffalo Bills 1973 (9-5)
- John Elway for the Denver Broncos 1983 (9-7)
- Kyle Boller for the Baltimore Ravens in 2003 (10-6)
- Kyle Orton for the Chicago Bears in 2005 (11-5) ... yep, THAT Kyle Orton
- Matt Ryan for the Atlanta Falcons in 2008 (11-5)
- Joe Flacco for the Baltimore Ravens in 2008 (11-5)
- Mark Sanchez for the New Jersey/York Jets in 2009 (9-7)
- Andy Dalton for the Cincinnati Bengals in 2011 (9-7)
- Andrew Luck for the Indianapolis Colts in 2012 (11-5)
- Robert Griffin for the Washington R!@#$%^& in 2012 (10-6)
- Russell Wilson for the Seattle Seahawks in 2012 (11-5)
- Geno Smith for the New Jersey/York Jets in 2013 (8-8)
Rookie QBs That Made the Playoffs: 10
- John Elway 1983 (lost AFC Wild Card)
- Kyle Boller 2003 (lost AFC Wild Card)
- Kyle Orton 2005 (lost Divisional Playoff) ... The Or-Ton!!
- Matt Ryan 2008 (lost NFC Wild Card)
- Joe Flacco 2008 (lost AFC Conference Championship) ... he actually won 2 games!
- Mark Sanchez 2009 (lost AFC Conference Championship) ... he actually won 2 games!
- Andy Dalton 2011 (lost AFC Wild Card)
- Andrew Luck 2012 (lost AFC Wild Card)
- Robert Griffin 2012 (lost NFC Wild Card)
- Russell Wilson 2012 (lost NFC Divisional Playoff) ... he actually won a game!
Rookie QBs That Made the Super Bowl: 0
Rookie QBs That Won the Super Bowl: 0
....well, maybe not. Can it be that the Cowboys can win a few (but not too many), convince Romo to take the money and sit in 2017, keep Witten from exploding and get some defensive help for next year? I sure hope so...cause this year aint The Year.
Best Case Scenario? 11-5 and 1+ playoff win (but with this defense??)
Worst Case Scenario? ....well, we've seen that already haven't we? (but, at least we beat the turd-skins!)
The main lesson here? Teams that start rookie QBs are not very good! Ladies and Gentlemen - your 2016-17 Dallas Cowboys Football Club!
Some interesting tidbits....
- the pace is increasing - from 1970 - 2009 just 25 teams started a rookie, from 2010 - 2015 a total of 13 teams started a rookie. Add 1 more for 2016.
- combined play-off record: 5 wins, 10 losses (55 years - 5 wins!)
- the Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts are the "winners" with 5 entries on the list
- The Tampa Bay Bucs come in a close second with 3 entries and the only "back-to-back"!